Brands in the News

Beer and the Power of Branding

8 May , 2017  

One of the benefits of being a professor at Kellogg is that you get to participate in  student events. Recently the Brew n Q club invited me to join them for a beer tasting. I shared some thoughts on branding in the beer industry to kick things off, then we sampled the beer. The event was an entertaining reminder of the power of brands.

The Results

The first tasting featured three mainstream brands: Bud Light, Coors Light and Miller Lite.

Prior to the tasting, the group strongly favored Coors Light; 52% indicated that was their favorite. Bud Light was a distant second with just 26% of the vote, and Miller Lite came in third with 24%.

After the tasting, however, things changed. Few people could tell the difference between the beverages; only about 20% of the panel could correctly identify which was which. The favorite beer was Miller Lite, with top scores from 43% of the panelists.

The second round featured some additional beers, including value brands Keystone Light, Busch Light and Miller High Life Light. Curiously, after having just realized that they actually preferred Miller Lite on an unbranded basis, Coors Light remained the clear favorite in the pre-tasting poll. It captured 46% of the vote.

This second tasting was even more confusing for people. Nobody was able to correctly identify the six options, and every beer received at least 10% of the vote. Bud Light was the favorite but not by much.

The Power of Brands

The event demonstrated why branding is so important.

First, branding can provide differentiation even when products are virtually identical. The Kellogg panel strongly supported Coors Light despite the fact that most people couldn’t tell one beer from the next.

Second, branding can override product inferiority. The panel continued to state a preference for Coors Light despite the fact the product itself wasn’t better. If anything, people preferred the taste of other brands.

Third, brand preference can endure even in the face of conflicting information. The panel didn’t score Coors Light well on an unbranded basis, but supported the brand despite this evidence.

Brands are important for every business, and they are a primary success driver for many. Creating sustainable differentiation is hard. A strong brand is one way to make it happen.



3 Responses

  1. Thom Disch says:

    There are similar taste tests done with vodka, where the best vodka is supposed to be the one with the least taste (flavored vodkas excepted) and the Brand winner is the premium brands but the participants cannot discern a difference in the quality or taste. Yet the price difference ranges by a multiple of 4 or more. (e.g. Grey Goose versus a private label) Yet everyone will say that they prefer Grey Goose even after all of the facts are known.

    This truly shows the value added benefit of Branding. Two psychologists, Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky won the nobel price in economics discussing how people may not always make rational decisions. I suspect that there is an extension of that argument that applies to branding.

  2. emitahill says:

    Fascinating. So it’s all about branding, and ultimately all about marketing, and behind the marketing, money, whether it’s beer or politicians. He who pays the piper the most wins, alas. I admit to buying my own light brand, Amstel, but was once told it’s dumb to buy any “light” or “lite” brand since they just contain more water.

  3. Stephen Calkins says:

    Embarrassing that a Kellogg beer club would hold a taste test among light beers which, almost by definition, have no taste! And I know it’s supposed to be America First, but not to include a single imported light beer (there are several)? You’re an awfully good sport to participate in such an event and leave the grumbling to me.

Leave a Reply

Archives

Conversation Across the Site

  • emitahill { Great analysis. I hadn't pinpointed the corporate enemy as clearly as you have here. But it follows over her earlier role in the Clinton administration... } – Elizabeth Warren's Savvy Marketing Strategy
  • Kathy Kraas { Let's hope the differentiation catches fire. Fingers crossed, fingers crossed. She still has much to do to penetrate very specific voting blocks. Hopefully she reads... } – Elizabeth Warren's Savvy Marketing Strategy
  • emitahill { Hilarious and accurate lesson, Tim. I already watched and loved Colbert's take on it. But DT heeds no lessons and observes no facts that contradict... } – Learning from Trump’s Weather Map Fiasco
  • jnemery { Well, you are right about the relationships, but you are wrong about the hogs not being better. A 4-H hog is hand-raised, the feed carefully... } – Learning from a 4-H Market Pig Auction
  • Anne { As soon as I found out Clorox bought Burt's Bees I knew they were going to start polluting the products! Come on...it's Clorox. Why would... } – Clorox Stumbles with Burt's Bees
  • emitahill { That's a devastating story and just as many smaller dairy farms are shutting down. Read Madeleine's story about Leelanau Cheese on FB. It will be... } – Fair Oaks Deals With a Brand Crisis
  • Read more Comments »

Collaborate with Tim

Tim helps companies around the world build great brands. To schedule a program or event click here. To learn more about Tim’s books, click here.