Cash for Clunkers: No Way to Build a Strong Business

7 Oct , 2009  

Anyone who has run a business knows two things about short term discounts.  First, big discounts feel great.  Nothing buoys the spirits like a quick and dramatic jump in sales. Second, this happy feeling rarely lasts.  Once the discount ends sales inevitably slump, often for a prolonged period of time.  The only way to get things moving quickly is to do another round of discounting.

The Cash for Clunkers program was a classic bit of short term discounting.  People who bought a new car received up to $4,500 from the government.   While it ran this program felt great; people rushed to dealers and bought cars.  They did exactly what one would expect them to do.  The program had a rather impressive impact on the entire U.S. economy, contributing to the rebounding economic indicators and a rising stock market.  Everything looked great.

But ultimately Cash for Clunkers had to end; it was a costly and unsustainable program.  And now sales are falling.  The monthly auto sales results released last weeek were shockingly bad.  General Motors sales were down 45% versus year ago.  Chrysler sales were off by 42%.  These are simply stunning declines.

Cash for Clunkers didn’t fix the economy and it didn’t fix General Motors or Chrysler.  Sales at GM and Chrysler will only rebound when people feel confident enough to invest in new cars and believe that the GM and Chrysler brands are the best ones for them.  Last week’s sales results show that we are a long way from that point.

One Response

  1. josh duncan says:


    Really enjoy following your blog. For those of us that have been out of school for a couple of years, it is a great way to keep up to date with your marketing strategy lessons.

    Thanks again,

    Josh Duncan
    TMP ’07

Leave a Reply


Conversation Across the Site

  • David Rose { This sounds very very difficult. You put alot of energy into it and obviosly care. I would suggest you focus on the room and let... }
  • M E Lesniak { I think you picked the wrong hill to stand on. You work at one of the most expensive degree factories in the country and I’m... }
  • Stephen Calkins { Forgiveness based on income? What if it is a wealthy family that figured borrowing cheaply was a good deal, but there is massive wealth? What... }
  • Todd Holscher { Transparency in pricing is a very good idea. Students will still susceptible to the influence of marketing and advertising by colleges, but it’s the right... }
  • Emita Hill { Vast sums of money. Alternatively provide more support to state schools so they can lower tuition and maybe to privates strictly for scholarships. }
  • David Rose { Tim, I dont think your views are balanced. You obviously are being paid by these loans. The money has been given to your university and... }
  • Read more Comments »

Collaborate with Tim

Tim helps companies around the world build great brands. To schedule a program or event click here. To learn more about Tim’s books, click here.