Career Advice

Lessons from Losing a House

21 Jan , 2011  

Over the past few weeks, my wife and I have been bidding on a rather nifty house in Chicago.  We finally reached an agreement with the sellers but at the last instant another buyer showed up with a significantly higher offer and got the house.

This was a huge disappointment for me.

When I look back on how my wife and I handled the bidding process, it is pretty clear that we bungled things: we didn’t decide we wanted the house until too late in the process.  We took too long to commit and we didn’t make remotely credible offers.

The real issue, however, was that we didn’t know what we wanted.  We weren’t looking for a house; this one just came along.  We had no goals and no plan.  My wife and I didn’t even agree on whether we should be looking at houses.  As a result, it took months for us to finally decide that it would be a great house for our family.

We won’t be looking at another house until we have agreed on some goals and a plan.

Many people approach marketing decisions the same way we approached our recent house question.  An attractive marketing tactic comes along and then people study it and try to decide if it is a good idea.  These days someone might march into a meeting and exclaim: “I think we should do a Groupon offer!  That is an incredible program.”

The problem is that this approach doesn’t usually lead to a good outcome.  It is hard to evaluate the different programs and difficult to get internal agreement.

Before looking at marketing ideas and tactics, it is best to have clear objectives and strategies.  When the overall plan is clear, it is much easier to make smart decisions.  If you know that building repeat business is your top priority, for example, then it is pretty easy to conclude that a frequent buyer program might make sense, and Groupon isn’t likely to be the best tactic.

A marketing plan creates clarity and builds alignment.  It should drive the marketing process.

A discussion about goals and plans helps when making life decisions, too.

One Response

  1. I definitely agree with you that it’s best to have clear marketing ideas and tactics. Take referral/recommendation marketing for example, it’s best to have a clear strategy for *how* to facilitate consumer conversations that occur around a brand, rather than approaching it willy-nilly. Sure an unclear plan is not guaranteed to fail but what it is, is chancy. Like you said, with pre-planning and knowledge of what the end objective is, it’s much easier to attain positive results.

Leave a Reply


Conversation Across the Site

  • Stephen Calkins { You were kind not to protest. For an argument that customer service is a key part of iPhone success, see story in today's New York... } – The High Cost of Poor Service
  • emitahill { Wonderful, Tim. I am wildly envious. Love all three of those cities and haven't been in far too long. } – Branding Observations from a Trip to Europe
  • Stephen Calkins { If Whitmire followed other advice you've given--live frugally and save regularly--at least he'll not have serious financial worries. He's 57 and presumably still receiving movie... } – Learning from Kermit’s Downfall
  • Dana { Charging fees is only one part of the racket HA is doing. They are also collecting all monies, collecting interest on the homeowners rents and... } – Why Homeaway’s New Fee Makes Sense
  • Jos. Smedley { Two Dogs, well today we received news from Home Away that starting SOON { "coming to a theatre near you" } there will be a... } – Why Homeaway’s New Fee Makes Sense
  • Jos. Smedley { Melissa, we could not agree with you more and pray that their chickens come home to roost ! Perhaps you would be kind enough to... } – Why Homeaway’s New Fee Makes Sense
  • Read more Comments »

Collaborate with Tim

Tim helps companies around the world build great brands. To schedule a program or event click here. To learn more about Tim’s books, click here.