The Cash for Clunkers Hangover

2 Sep , 2010  

This week automakers released sales numbers for August.  The results were dismal.  According to The Wall Street Journal, sales in the U.S. fell 21% versus 2009.  Sales at Nissan, GM, Toyota and Honda all fell more than 25%.

These results aren’t a surprise, since U.S. government’s Cash for Clunkers program boosted sales last year.  The Cash for Clunkers program gave some auto buyers a credit of up to $4,500 on the purchase of a new car.  Essentially, this was a huge short-term discount, funded by the taxpayers.

Big discounts like Cash for Clunkers have a huge impact on sales.  When the discount is in place, sale will almost always jump.  When the discount ends, sales fall.  And if the discount isn’t offered the following year, the year to year comparisons will be grim.

Discounting is a bit like partying.  Everything is wonderful and fun while the party rolls on.  But inevitably the party ends and when the sun comes up the hangover remains.  And in general, the bigger the party, the bigger the hangover.

Companies need to be very careful when it comes to discounting; the short-term jump is pleasant but fleeting. 

Heinz this week announced that sales were up in the latest quarter, in part because the company cut the price of ketchup at Wal-Mart to $1 for a 40-ounce bottle.  This offer drove a lot of volume, as one would expect.  But it was just a short-term gain.  Ketchup doesn’t usually cause hangovers, but this offer surely will.

One Response

  1. […] dangers of relying on sales to drive your business and what it can do to your brand.  In his last post is he used the cash for clunkers program as an example.   Prof. Calking warns, Discounting is a […]

Leave a Reply


Conversation Across the Site

  • Bonnie Halpern { Thank you so much for another wonderful webinar. I attend the in-person event every year in NYC. I am so happy that you had a... }
  • Tammy Williams { Always enjoy your perspective, Tim, thanks for sharing your insights and expertise. It's truly going to be an interesting game! }
  • Katherine E Brown { It really depends on the fair and the kid. Our local fair has 80% feeder pigs bought from auction or a local person or two... }
  • Todd { Thank you for this insight, Professor. Students rarely have any insight into the mind of a professor or teacher at any level. Come to think... }
  • Mark Sheldon { Very interesting. Thank you and I think your analysis is generally correct. The one thing I would add is that in a small zoom class... }
  • Marty { Ford , built for change ? This is the company Hank almost bankrupted by refusing to replace the model T }
  • Read more Comments »

Collaborate with Tim

Tim helps companies around the world build great brands. To schedule a program or event click here. To learn more about Tim’s books, click here.