Super Bowl Ads

CareerBuilder Takes a Pass

23 Jan , 2013  

One of the advertisers I’ll miss seeing on the Super Bowl this year is CareerBuilder.

CareerBuilder first advertised on the game back in 2005. The brand was quite new at the time; Monster.com dominated the space and CareerBuilder was a much smaller challenger. CareerBuilder ran a charming commercial featuring the now iconic chimps. The Kellogg Super Bowl Advertising Review panel gave it a B, a good grade (the average grade is a C). The chimps did even better for CareerBuilder in 2006; the Kellogg panel gave that spot one of the top scores of the year, an A.

CareerBuilder moved away from the chimps in 2007, running an ad that compared office life to surviving in a jungle. Perhaps the brand’s lowest moment came in 2008 when its Super Bowl ad featured a heart graphically emerging from a lady’s chest. The Kellogg panel gave CareerBuilder a D that year.

CareerBuilder rebounded in 2009 and 2010, receiving an A and a B. The 2010 spot featured people with no pants. Then, at long last, Career Builder brought back the chimps in 2011 and 2012.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=xYJ9EW50h1I

During this time, CareerBuilder grew to become a category leader, eventually overtaking Monster.com. The Super Bowl clearly played an important part in this growth.

So why is CareerBuilder taking a pass in 2013?

The company isn’t offering much of an explanation; the official line is that CareerBuilder is spending on other things, which I’m certain is true.

I suspect there are several reasons.

One problem is simple; the chimps are an issue. Over the years, animal rights groups criticized CareerBuilder for using chimps in its spot. The criticism reached a new peak in 2012.

Without the chimps, CareerBuilder would have to develop a new campaign. This is costly and complicated and, as the team at CareerBuilder has learned, not easy to do when you have established equity in an iconic image like the chimps.

It wasn’t clear how much the Super Bowl was doing for Career Builder, either. After eight years, how much more growth is there? What is the return on investment, anyway? The only way to really know is to skip a year and see what happens. This is a real life test market.

I suspect the marketers at CareerBuilder will again be watching this year’s Super Bowl with great interest. This year, however, they won’t be watching to see how well their ad does; they will be watching to see what happens when they sit out.

I predict we will see them back on the Super Bowl in 2014.


Archives

Conversation Across the Site

  • Thom Disch { There are similar taste tests done with vodka, where the best vodka is supposed to be the one with the least taste (flavored vodkas excepted)... } – Beer and the Power of Branding
  • emitahill { Fascinating. So it's all about branding, and ultimately all about marketing, and behind the marketing, money, whether it's beer or politicians. He who pays the... } – Beer and the Power of Branding
  • Stephen Calkins { Embarrassing that a Kellogg beer club would hold a taste test among light beers which, almost by definition, have no taste! And I know it's... } – Beer and the Power of Branding
  • Emma Stockdale { I'm curious how much of this resulted as a byproduct of broader company culture / official protocol (why did they board the plane if they... } – United’s Branding Disaster
  • emitahill { Really bad. I waited 10 hours in an airport Saturday. Problem was that the airline had not grounded planes and canceled flights in really bad... } – United’s Branding Disaster
  • Alain Weber { Indeed Tim, this is a rough day for United. This brutal action was certainly unexpected. But, upon reflecting on general airlines' attitude toward passengers, I... } – United’s Branding Disaster
  • Read more Comments »

Collaborate with Tim

Tim helps companies around the world build great brands. To schedule a program or event click here. To learn more about Tim’s books, click here.