Defending Your Brand

Defending with Patents

8 Oct , 2012  

Today’s New York Times has a wonderful article about the patent wars currently raging in the technology industry. You can read the article here:

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/08/technology/patent-wars-among-tech-giants-can-stifle-competition.html?hp

Securing and enforcing patents is a classic defensive strategy; I spend a fair bit of time on it in my new book, Defending Your Brand. In theory it is all quite simple. You invent an idea, secure a patent and then own the concept for many years.

Apple is a master at using patents. The company received more than 4,000 patents since 2000 and is willing to enforce them, as the recent battle with Samsung demonstrates. This is one way Apple defends.

The reality is that patent battles quickly become very messy. It is hard to enforce patents. Competitors can challenge them. Patent wars can quickly escalate as companies secure dozens of different patents and then file suit to enforce them.

The article in today’s paper includes a wonderful graphic showing the current state of affairs in technology. Apple is suing Samsung and Samsung is suing Apple. Apple is also suing Nokia, Motorola (now part of Google) and RIM. Motorola is suing RIM and RIM is suing back. They all are suing HTC. You can sum it up by saying that just about everyone is suing everyone and the lawyers are becoming very wealthy.

I suspect that eventually the battles might settle down; the industry leaders may recognize that there is little to be gained with all this litigation.

One executive in the medical device industry explained to me how things work there: every established company can sue all the other companies. So litigation is relatively infrequent; one suit will just lead to another. It is mutually assured destruction (or at least mutually assured legal expenses).

Still, patents can protect existing industry players from outside attack. Any new entrant will likely face significant legal challenges. This becomes a major barrier to entry.

Steve Jobs apparently believed deeply in patents as important defensive tools. On this point he was, as usual, correct.


Leave a Reply

Archives

Conversation Across the Site

  • priyavanjeri { I absolutely agree with you. Governments are constantly criticizing pharma companies for shooting up prices but instead should divery their energy and resources towards developing... } – Pharmaceutical Pricing, Markets and Ebola
  • Fabio { How Pharmaceutical companies can help? Check it here http://online.wsj.com/articles/johnson-johnson-to-begin-testing-ebola-vaccine-in-january-1413957003 If we didn't need those companies, why government agencies and Universities didn't work on a solution... } – Pharmaceutical Pricing, Markets and Ebola
  • manishaaithal1 { PM Mr. Modi has made a impact in his tenure of state chief minister of Gujarat, has taken state leadership scope to a newer level.... } – Rebranding India
  • manishaaithal1 { Ebola outbreak is best example to re-state that healthcare can not be treated with mere wealth generation / business creation motive. Healthcare needs to be... } – Pharmaceutical Pricing, Markets and Ebola
  • Andrei Mitran { National rebranding - I admire the brave move. However, I do not think there are any quick rebranding alternatives for Prime Minister Modi. Investors wil... } – Rebranding India
  • David { I understand the rational but I am not sure it is completely built on facts ... The fact that on one hand many pharmaceuticals companies... } – Pharmaceutical Pricing, Markets and Ebola
  • Read more Comments »

Collaborate with Tim

Tim helps companies around the world build great brands. To schedule a program or event click here. To learn more about Tim’s books, click here.