Brands in the News

Student Loans and Buyer’s Regret

7 Apr , 2016  

One of the big issues in the U.S. today is student loans. People are astonished at the debt young people are dealing with, and presidential candidates are proposing various solutions that range from lower interest rates to debt forgiveness.

This all makes sense. Student loan debt is increasing at a dramatic pace because colleges are raising prices every year, and they’re raising them at rates that often far exceed inflation. Many young people are finishing college with $30,000, $50,000, or more in loans. For someone starting out, this is a significant burden, enough to make some people claim that student loan debt is slowing our economy by reducing household formation. The Wall Street Journal ran this remarkable chart today:

Loans

One of the strange parts of the discussion, however, is the lack of buyer’s regret. Graduates complain about their debt. Many express shock and outrage. Few, however, seem to regret their college decision.

This is puzzling. If the debt was such a problem, then logically people should regret their college choice and the associated financial implications. But few people say this. Graduates seem to be happy with their college experience and dismayed with the debt involved, but free of regrets overall.

In some ways, this is like a couple that goes out to a fancy dinner, has a wonderful time, and then is unhappy when they get the credit card bill. Still, they don’t regret going to the dinner–it was a lovely night.

At some point, this all might change. People might start saying, “Wow, I really regret going to the expensive college and taking on so much debt. I should have gone somewhere less expensive.”

This would encourage prospective students to ask the question: Is this college really worth the price? Application numbers at expensive institutions would then fall, especially at schools that don’t have a powerful brand. This would force schools to improve the value proposition through lower prices or a better experience. Tuition would decline and this would lead to lower debt.

For the moment, however, most schools have more than enough demand to fill classes and so the tuition continues to go up, along with student debt. With the lack of buyer’s regret among college graduates, the situation isn’t likely to change anytime soon.



3 Responses

  1. Andrei Mitran says:

    Fantastic (and timely) post. My wife and I just had a conversation on the apparent lack of buyer’s remorse..

  2. Ken Templin says:

    Tim:

    Good post. I have been looking for the impetus that would move Universities to be more cost effective.
    They have taken advantage of the government backed student loan programs to increase their “revenues” well beyond reasonable cost pressures. If left to market forces (read non government), they wouldn’t have be able to continue the higher education cost trend as long as they did.
    We can only hope the current generation of college students will be more debt conscious than their predecessors.

    Ken Templin

  3. abshtm says:

    I think this is starting to change. I have a daughter about to apply to colleges next year and this is very much the conversation in our house and among many people we know. I also read a lot of articles and published data about this (e.g. “Best Value Colleges” articles, etc.). However, we do also know plenty of people who continue to pursue the prestige of an institution without regard to its costs and long-term costs. I want to say that many of the latter people either have the resources or seem to be concentrated around the northeastern U.S. where prestige is still considered a virtue.

Leave a Reply

Archives

Conversation Across the Site

  • Stephen Calkins { You were kind not to protest. For an argument that customer service is a key part of iPhone success, see story in today's New York... } – The High Cost of Poor Service
  • emitahill { Wonderful, Tim. I am wildly envious. Love all three of those cities and haven't been in far too long. } – Branding Observations from a Trip to Europe
  • Stephen Calkins { If Whitmire followed other advice you've given--live frugally and save regularly--at least he'll not have serious financial worries. He's 57 and presumably still receiving movie... } – Learning from Kermit’s Downfall
  • Dana { Charging fees is only one part of the racket HA is doing. They are also collecting all monies, collecting interest on the homeowners rents and... } – Why Homeaway’s New Fee Makes Sense
  • Jos. Smedley { Two Dogs, well today we received news from Home Away that starting SOON { "coming to a theatre near you" } there will be a... } – Why Homeaway’s New Fee Makes Sense
  • Jos. Smedley { Melissa, we could not agree with you more and pray that their chickens come home to roost ! Perhaps you would be kind enough to... } – Why Homeaway’s New Fee Makes Sense
  • Read more Comments »

Collaborate with Tim

Tim helps companies around the world build great brands. To schedule a program or event click here. To learn more about Tim’s books, click here.